Skip to content
Log in

academy · special situations

Academy

How to read this case page

Each deal's case page, tab by tab: what each block measures, how to read it, which signals warn and what to do about them. Values the page lacks read N/D: they are never estimated.

  1. 1 · Tab: Header

    Header: Company in Reorganisation, Court & Court Order

    Identifies the emerging company, the Bankruptcy Court, the case number and the effective date.

    What it is
    The control panel auditing the orderly exit from bankruptcy under Title 11 of the US Bankruptcy Code (Chapter 11).
    How to read it
    Check the court confirmation of the Plan (§ 1129) and the filing of Form 8-K Item 2.01, ensuring the old common equity has been extinguished and the new shares are issued free of encumbrances.
    Red flags
    No final confirmation order, or unresolved appeals by the U.S. Trustee or subordinated committees.
    Green flags
    A Plan of Reorganisation confirmed by a final court order, unanimously backed by the senior debt classes, with substantial consummation declared.
    What to do
    Check in Form 8-K Item 2.01 that the Effective Date has occurred and the new shares have already been distributed.
    Concepts and formulas (3)
    Plan of Reorganization
    The court-sanctioned agreement setting the forced swap of old debt for new equity, the liquidity injection and the new balance-sheet structure.
    Confirmation Order (§ 1129)
    The order issued by the bankruptcy judge approving the plan and making it binding on all creditors and shareholders.
    Registration Exemption (§ 1145)
    The Bankruptcy Code provision allowing new shares to be issued to creditors and traded freely without filing an SEC Form S-1 registration statement.

  2. 2 · Tab: Summary

    Quantitative Telemetry: Reorg Value vs Spot Price

    Spot price, diluted Reorg Value, discount to that value, spot EV/EBITDA multiple and IRR.

    What it is
    The real-time panel calculating the mathematical asymmetry between a price depressed by forced selling and the value of the reorganised equity.
    How to read it
    The spot price implies a pro-forma EV/EBITDA multiple: compare it with the one the financial adviser models in the Disclosure Statement and with sector peers.
    Red flags
    Trap 1 (Inflated Reorg Value): assuming the Reorg Value is a guaranteed acquisition price rather than an expert estimate for the court's feasibility test.
    Green flags
    A discount of more than 25% to the diluted Reorg Price, backed by EV/EBITDA multiples below 3.0x.
    What to do
    Always calculate the discount on a 'Fully Diluted' basis (including the MIP pool and warrants), never on basic shares.
    Concepts and formulas (4)
    Implied Reorg Price (Fully Diluted)
    The court-approved equity value divided by the total number of shares, including the MIP incentive pool and warrants.
    Post-Reorg Spot Discount
    The percentage difference between the market price and the Plan's expert valuation approved by the court.
    Spot EV/EBITDA Multiple
    The opening multiple of the newly listed company; it shows whether the market is over-punishing the value of the assets.
    Year-1 Pro-Forma EBITDA
    The operating projection agreed by the investment bankers in the Disclosure Statement for the first year after exit.

  3. 3 · Tab: Summary

    Entry Window into the Post-Exit Discount & Asymmetry

    Weighs convergence towards sector multiples against the risk of absorbing the paper (§ 1145).

    What it is
    The analysis that determines whether the potential return compensates for the time capital is tied up while institutional selling is digested; on the case page it is read through the asymmetry and the RAAS (P·Spread − (1−P)·Downside).
    How to read it
    With a deleveraged balance sheet and long-term contracts, the re-rating towards the multiple modelled in the Disclosure Statement is the source of the upside; the case page's asymmetry sets it against the downside.
    Red flags
    Deterioration in day rates or falling fleet utilisation while the forced selling is being digested.
    Green flags
    A share buyback announced with the cash left over after exit, to speed up the absorption of the credit funds' paper.
    What to do
    Require an Upside/Downside asymmetry ratio of at least 2.5x.
    Concepts and formulas (2)
    Structural Deleveraging
    A permanent reduction in net debt that frees cash flow for buybacks or productive investment.
    Cash-Flow Safety Margin
    The surplus of operating free cash over capex needs and servicing of the new debt.

  4. 4 · Tab: Critical path

    Bankruptcy Critical Path: From Chapter 11 Petition to Emergence

    Milestone timeline: Bankruptcy Petition -> Disclosure Statement -> Class Voting -> Confirmation Order -> NYSE Exit -> ASC 852 Fresh-Start.

    What it is
    The 8-to-18-month legal path taking the company from temporary insolvency back to the capital markets.
    How to read it
    The decisive milestone is the Confirmation Order and the Effective Date: it marks the cancellation of encumbrances and the return of control to management.
    Red flags
    Repeated extensions of the exclusivity period without a consensual plan, driving up legal costs.
    Green flags
    A consensual process backed by a majority of the senior bondholder group, allowing exit in under 9 months.
    What to do
    Follow the bankruptcy judge's hearing calendar through the court's official portal (PACER or Kroll Restructuring).
    Concepts and formulas (4)
    Confirmation Order
    The final ruling of the bankruptcy judge approving the plan of reorganisation and making it binding on all creditors.
    Effective Date
    The day on which all conditions precedent are met and the company formally emerges from Chapter 11.
    Form 8-K Item 2.01
    The regulatory disclosure filed with the SEC certifying consummation of the Plan and the acquisition/disposition of assets.
    Claims Bar Date
    The deadline for creditors to file their debt claims with the court.

  5. 5 · Tab: Thesis & checklist

    Industrial Thesis: Deleveraging & Market Leadership

    The rationale of the rescue: bankruptcy cleaned up the balance sheet without destroying the Tier 1 assets or the international operating contracts.

    What it is
    The fundamental analysis showing that the problem was purely financial (cyclical over-leverage) and not one of viability of the underlying business.
    How to read it
    A viable rescue operates assets that lead their sector, but no longer carries financial burdens that choke its operating cash flows.
    Red flags
    Technologically obsolete businesses where bankruptcy only postpones an inevitable liquidation for lack of a business model.
    Green flags
    Companies with iconic brands, unassailable barriers to entry and tangible assets with high replacement value.
    What to do
    Invest only in restructurings where the underlying operating business is profitable before interest and taxes.
    Concepts and formulas (3)
    Financial vs Operating Insolvency
    A critical distinction: financial insolvency is a balance-sheet problem solvable with haircuts; operating insolvency reflects a business in decline.
    Post-Bankruptcy Return on Capital Employed (ROCE)
    Measures the profitability of the new deleveraged balance sheet; it tends to jump as the book equity base shrinks.
    Private Capital Backing
    The presence of leading private equity firms (Apollo, Centerbridge, Knighthead) leading the capital injection.

  6. 6 · Tab: Thesis & checklist

    Investor Control Checklist: The 7 Key Questions (5 Blocks)

    A control protocol in 5 blocks: Court Confirmation, expert Reorg EV, Net Debt, MIP Dilution/Overhang and NYSE Trading.

    What it is
    The forensic audit guide for ruling out value traps and selecting only high-asymmetry rescues.
    How to read it
    Each block examines one pillar of the exit from bankruptcy. Affirmative answers in all 5 blocks confirm the trade has a proven margin of safety.
    Red flags
    Residual litigation not closed in the Confirmation Order that could revive past liabilities.
    Green flags
    Every question backed by final orders of the bankruptcy judge and filed SEC Form 8-K Item 2.01 documents.
    What to do
    Use this protocol before buying any share that has been through a court-supervised reorganisation.
    Concepts and formulas (3)
    Chapter 11 5-Block Protocol
    A method that audits: I. Finality of the court order, II. Quality of the deleveraging, III. Dilution, IV. Free cash and V. Warrant structure.
    Certificate of Substantial Consummation
    Court confirmation that the company has carried out all payments and issuances ordered in the plan.
    Audit of Bankruptcy Professional Fees
    Verification that the lawyers' and investment banks' fees have been finally settled.

  7. 7 · Tab: Market

    Post-Bankruptcy Recovery Curve & Regular Trading

    Price evolution: extinction of the old shares on OTC, start of trading of the new shares on a main market, and the phase of absorbing forced selling.

    What it is
    The chart documenting the company's metamorphosis: from the court cancellation of the old equity to institutional price discovery on the exchange.
    How to read it
    Watch the 'liquidity purgatory' phase: the new shares suffer initial technical selling pressure before starting to converge towards the Reorg Value. Without enough price history, the case page shows N/D: never a synthetic series.
    Red flags
    Trap 4 (OTC Purgatory): companies whose new shares are stuck on the OTC market (Pink Sheets) with no analysts or institutional liquidity.
    Green flags
    Relisting and direct debut on a top-tier market (NYSE / NASDAQ) from Day 1 with a new CUSIP.
    What to do
    Make sure you trade only the new ordinary shares issued under the new CUSIP, never the old suspended securities.
    Concepts and formulas (4)
    Direct NYSE/NASDAQ Listing
    Immediate trading on a senior exchange without passing through the illiquid purgatory of the Pink Sheets (OTC).
    Cancellation of Old Shares
    The irreversible extinction of the pre-bankruptcy equity securities under the Absolute Priority Rule.
    Paper Absorption Curve
    The period (generally 30-90 days) during which value investors absorb the credit funds' dumping.
    New CUSIP / ISIN Code
    A unique identifier issued for the new securities, preventing any confusion with the liquidated security.

  8. 8 · Tab: Evidence

    Evidence: Disclosure Statement & Mandate Mismatch

    Reading the filings: how much of the equity ends up with debt funds forced to sell (§ 1145) and how much the management MIP pool dilutes.

    What it is
    Reading the court filings and the Form 8-K. It detects shareholder concentration in non-natural holders (creditors) and the overhang risk.
    How to read it
    When a meaningful share of the equity ends up with credit funds whose mandates prohibit holding common stock, a temporary dumping is forced.
    Red flags
    Trap 3 (Prolonged Credit Overhang): creditor concentration above 60% with low daily volume, stretching the selling drip over more than 6 months.
    Green flags
    Anchor sponsors with lock-up agreements that absorb the paper of the exiting funds.
    What to do
    Wait for the initial daily volume to normalise after the first 2-4 weeks of trading before building the position to its target size.
    Concepts and formulas (4)
    Mandate Mismatch
    Credit funds' statutory inability to keep equity in their portfolios after the conversion.
    Forced Dumping
    Price-insensitive selling by bond portfolios to comply with their restrictive investment mandates.
    Management Incentive Plan (MIP Pool)
    An equity reserve (typically 5%-10%) allocated to management to align interests after bankruptcy.
    Backstop Commitment Fees
    Fees and free shares given to creditors who guarantee the exit capital injections.

  9. 9 · Tab: Reorganisation

    Chapter 11 Genome: Debt Cancellation & Net Cash

    The pillars of the exit balance sheet: cancellation of the legacy debt, issuance of new senior notes and the exit cash (net cash).

    What it is
    The financial architecture of the newly listed, bankruptcy-free company. It compares the old unpayable debt with the cleaned-up post-restructuring balance sheet.
    How to read it
    Analyse the Reorg Enterprise Value and the post-emergence net cash position, which sets the opening leverage (net debt / EBITDA).
    Red flags
    Trap 5 (Industrial Insolvency / Chapter 22): cosmetic restructurings where the remaining debt exceeds 3.5x EBITDA or the business is in secular decline.
    Green flags
    Emergence with a Net Cash position or leverage below 1.0x EBITDA, giving the entity complete protection.
    What to do
    Check that projected EBITDA covers interest on the new debt more than 6x and that maturities are more than 5 years out.
    Concepts and formulas (4)
    Debt-for-Equity Swap
    An exchange in which creditors swap their defaulted senior bonds for 100% of the new listed equity.
    Post-Emergence Net Cash Position
    The optimal financial position in which exit cash exceeds the total new senior debt issued.
    Fresh-Start Accounting (ASC 852)
    The accounting standard requiring all assets and liabilities to be revalued at fair value in the opening balance sheet.
    'Chapter 22' Risk
    A second bankruptcy caused by not cutting enough debt or by a business model in structural contraction.

  10. 10 · Tab: Traps

    Audit of the 5 Forensic Traps in Reorganisations

    Strict expert control: Trap 1 (Reorg Value), Trap 2 (Hidden Dilution), Trap 3 (Overhang), Trap 4 (OTC Market) and Trap 5 (Chapter 22).

    What it is
    The institutional safety protocol that separates viable restructuring trades from bankruptcy value traps.
    How to read it
    A trade only earns maximum conviction if it clears the 5 traps: a conservative Reorg EV, controlled MIP dilution, absorbed overhang, NYSE listing and a leading business.
    Red flags
    Bankrupt companies diluting more than 25% with warrants/rights offerings to creditors, or still losing market share after exit.
    Green flags
    A trade that clears all 5 tests: a depressed spot multiple, a capped MIP, NYSE listing, positive net cash and modern assets.
    What to do
    Always consult the audit of the 5 traps before making any investment decision in post-bankruptcy shares.
    Concepts and formulas (5)
    Trap 1: Integrity of the Reorg Value
    The Reorg EV is a feasibility estimate for the court, not a guaranteed tender offer price.
    Trap 2: Hidden Exit Dilution
    The impact of the management incentive pool (MIP) and discounted pre-emptive subscription rights.
    Trap 3: Prolonged Overhang (§ 1145)
    Forced sales of 40%-70% blocks held by debt funds that take months to drain.
    Trap 4: OTC Purgatory
    Lack of liquidity and a statutory bar on funds while the stock trades on the Pink Sheets without an official relisting.
    Trap 5: Industrial Insolvency (Chapter 22)
    A debt haircut does not fix a broken business model or the technical obsolescence of the assets.

Key-question checklist

Block I: Legal Framework, Court Confirmation and Effective Date

  • In which court and under which insolvency framework was the Plan processed, and what is the official Effective Date?

    Find it in the confirmation order: the US bankruptcy court, the case number and the judge who issued the order (§ 1129). The formal exit from bankruptcy is the Effective Date, which the company certifies by filing Form 8-K Item 2.01 with the SEC.

Block II: Reorg Enterprise Value and Exit Multiples (Trap 1)

  • What Reorg Enterprise Value range did the financial advisers validate in the Disclosure Statement, and what EV/EBITDA multiple does it imply?

    The Disclosure Statement sets out the financial adviser's expert Reorg Enterprise Value, with its range, and the projected EBITDA on which the exit multiple is calculated. Compare it with the sector peer median and with the multiple implied at the spot price; it is an estimate for the court's feasibility test, not a guaranteed price.

Block III: Balance-Sheet Clean-Up and Net Cash Position

  • What is the exact post-emergence Net Debt, and how does the opening leverage compare with the sector average?

    Compare the legacy debt cancelled with the new senior notes issued and the pro-forma exit cash: if cash exceeds the new debt, the company emerges in a NET CASH position (negative leverage on EBITDA). Set that opening leverage against that of sector competitors.

Block IV: Trap Audit: Mandate Mismatch, Section 1145, MIP and Warrants (Traps 2 and 3)

  • What share of the new equity is held by debt funds required to sell under Section 1145, and how much does the MIP pool dilute?

    Identify in the plan how much of the equity goes to debt and credit funds whose mandates require them to sell equity. The shares are exempt from registration under Section 1145 of the Bankruptcy Code, which causes a temporary flow of forced selling (forced dumping). Calculate the MIP dilution and its vesting schedule.

  • Has the full cancellation, for no value, of the old share capital (Old Common Stock) and the issuance of a new CUSIP been confirmed?

    It must be stated that all the old equity was cancelled and extinguished without economic consideration under the Absolute Priority Rule, and that the new ordinary shares were issued under a new CUSIP.

Block V: Trading Venue, Uplisting and Operating Viability (Traps 4 and 5)

  • On which market do the new shares trade (NYSE/NASDAQ vs OTC), and when is the audited ASC 852 balance sheet published?

    Unlike restructurings stuck on the Pink Sheets (OTC), the desirable outcome is a direct debut on NYSE or NASDAQ. Fresh-Start accounting (ASC 852) is formalised in the first periodic report after exit (Form 10-Q), revaluing the assets at market value.

  • What do the card's DRI and the case page's RAAS show, and what is the underlying industrial viability?

    The DRI is the Deal Reliability Index, and the case page's RAAS weighs spread and downside by probability: P·Spread − (1−P)·Downside. Neither replaces the industrial analysis: the company must operate leading, modern assets that rule out the risk of a second bankruptcy (Chapter 22).

See this family's deals →